TL;DR
A PC builder ordered an RTX 5070 from Amazon and received unrelated items including a DVD rewriter and a broken logic board. The incident exposes ongoing return scams and risks in online hardware purchases.
A PC enthusiast received a package from Amazon containing a DVD rewriter, an old broken logic board, and a mousepad instead of the RTX 5070 graphics card they ordered, highlighting ongoing return scam issues.
The victim, a hardware enthusiast, ordered a MSI Ventus 2X RTX 5070 from Amazon, purchased by a friend for approximately 605 euros ($700). When the package arrived, it weighed the same as a graphics card but contained unrelated items: a broken logic board from an early 2000s Kenwood AV receiver, a DVD rewriter, and a mousepad.
According to the victim, the package was shipped and sold directly by Amazon. The item was a gift, and the buyer provided proof of purchase. Experts suggest this was likely a scam swap, where someone previously bought the item, replaced its contents with junk, and then filed a return request citing personal preference. The package’s weight remained consistent, allowing the scam to pass basic checks and return back into circulation.
This incident underscores how return fraud schemes exploit Amazon’s logistics and return policies, especially before the platform’s recent measures to reduce commingling of products. The scam’s mechanics involve swapping genuine items with counterfeit or unrelated objects, then returning the package for a refund, which can be exploited by malicious actors.
Impact of Return Scams on Hardware Purchases
This case highlights the persistent risks of return scams in online hardware shopping, especially for high-value items like graphics cards. Such scams can lead to consumers receiving unrelated or defective products, eroding trust in e-commerce platforms. It also demonstrates how scammers manipulate logistics and return policies, complicating efforts to ensure product authenticity and customer protection.
I3C Laptop Lock, Combination Security Lock Cable with Keys and Anchor Plate, Anti Theft Lock for Business Electronics, Monitors, Tablets, Smart Phones (2 Laptop Locks Head)
✔TWIN LOCK DESIGN: Two devices can be locked and connected at the same time. If you have two…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Background of Return Fraud and Amazon’s Policies
Return scams involving product swapping and fake returns have increased in recent years, exploiting weaknesses in logistics and verification processes. Amazon has implemented measures, such as ending its commingling program last year, to reduce such fraud, but cases still occur. The incident with the RTX 5070 adds to ongoing concerns about the safety of online hardware purchases, especially from trusted sources like official stores and direct sellers.
“This type of scam relies on the weight and packaging similarity to deceive basic return checks, making it difficult to detect without thorough inspection.”
— an anonymous researcher
2Pcs 14”x16” Expanding Foam Packaging for PC, Electronics & Irregular Items – Shockproof Expandable Packing Foam, Protective Material for Fragile Devices & Custom Shapes
PERFECT PACKING FOAM: Expandable foam bags, expanding packing foam protect kinds of items, such as: instrument, meter, motor,…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Extent of the Scam and Future Risks
It is not yet clear how widespread this specific scam method is or whether Amazon is actively investigating this case. The full scope of similar incidents remains uncertain, and whether the platform will implement additional safeguards is also unknown.
Kaisi Professional Electronics Opening Pry Tool Repair Kit with Metal Spudger Non-Abrasive Nylon Spudgers and Anti-Static Tweezers for Cellphone iPhone Laptops Tablets and More, 20 Piece
Kaisi 20 pcs opening pry tools kit for smart phone,laptop,computer tablet,electronics, apple watch, iPad, iPod, Macbook, computer, LCD…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Next Steps for the Victim and Platform
The victim plans to contact Amazon for a refund and investigation. Amazon may review the case and potentially tighten verification procedures. Consumers are advised to remain vigilant, especially when purchasing high-value hardware from online platforms, and to verify product authenticity upon receipt.
Big Heavy Duty Stainless Steel Padlock with Key,high Security Shipping Container Padlocks,Bolt Cutter Proof Lock,10mm Thick Large Padlock for Outdoor,keyed Unbreakable Anti Theft Chain Lock (70mm)
Large-Sized Lock: Please carefully check the lock dimensions to ensure it not too large for your needs..This lock…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
How can I avoid falling victim to similar return scams?
Always verify the contents upon arrival, especially for high-value items. Use secure payment methods, and consider inspecting items thoroughly before initiating a return. Keep records and photos of the package and contents.
Contact the seller or platform immediately, document the received items with photos, and request a return or refund. Report the incident to the platform’s customer service for investigation.
Does Amazon have measures to prevent such scams?
Yes, Amazon has implemented policies like ending the commingling program and improving return verification. However, scams can still occur, so consumers should remain cautious and verify items upon receipt.
Is this incident common for high-value PC components?
While not everyday occurrences, high-value components like GPUs are frequent targets for return scams due to their high resale value. Consumers should be especially vigilant with such items.
Source: Tom’s Hardware: For The Hardcore PC Enthusiast
